Dune book 1 through 8 - Herbert, Frank and Brian

This post has 3 comments

• 
  grumblle321
  January 25th, 2013
  

  Hunters and Sandworms of Dune are total crap, dont read them unless you are prepared to a fanfiction grade, awfully inconsistent storyline full of deadplots, “out of place” characters - and a ridiculous ending compared to which the ending of Lost is a Shakespearean masterpiece. Seriously, Hunders and Sandworms of Dune (or Shitworms of Dune as they call it in some cyrcles, a well-earned name, I must say) is not an ending, but some kind of grotesque parody of the original Dune book. Just to give you a hint, there come things like: seaworms, ghola spamfest (including 2 Paul Atreides), space jews, some deity called Oracle of Time capable of sucking AI out of existence… if you want to preserve decent memories of the Dune novels, just consider Chapterhouse an open ended ending to the series. The only stuff worth reading from BH/KJA is “The Road to Dune”, in which there is an alternate, unpublished version of the original Dune novel.

  Dune book 1 through 8 - Herbert, Frank and Brian
• 
  no3gods
  February 24th, 2013
  

  I think most of the prequels were okay, and taken for what they are, were a fun read (except for the constant reiterating.) You are right though, the last book is atrocious.

  Dune book 1 through 8 - Herbert, Frank and Brian
• 
  Doom187
  April 4th, 2024
  

  grumblle321, Jews were in Chapterhouse, FYI

  Dune book 1 through 8 - Herbert, Frank and Brian

Add a comment (please log in before commenting)